Friday, May 29, 2009

SPM只限考10科 - 教育部好心做坏事

尊敬的教长宣布从明年开始,将限制学生只能报考十科。我不怀疑教育部是从正面的出发点来做这个决定,过就这样雷厉风行的办,肯定会有很对问题和盲点浮现。

首先我们知道SPM是以中四和中五的课程为考试内容。教长这一个宣布一旦实行,那么将让那些已经准备多过10个科目半年的学生努力付诸流水。虽然距离明年SPM还有一年多的时间,不过这个决定会深刻打击学生的努力,站在教育的角度,这个决定做的很仓促。

其次,这个政策难道真的可以有效解决奖学金的纠纷吗?很明显的这个是治标不治本。奖学金分配不公起源于两个原因 官僚化和拿破仑式的作风剥夺优秀生的机会,以及从根本上SPM制造了太多的“优秀生”,那已经到了泛滥的地步了。如果我们仔细想想,问题可能没有解决,反而更复杂了。以后SPM最顶级的考生就成绩只会有10A+,那么又要在这一群学生当中决定孰优孰劣呢?以前还可以看看是否当中有超水准的,现在只怕 “老鼠”、“老虎”,傻傻分不清楚!

更严重的是,这个就成为了公共服务局官僚的借口,以现有的奖学金数目不能满足所有10A+优秀生而连上诉的门槛都关掉(不好意思,马华您将少了其中一个最大的功能)。试想想当公共服务局告诉您因为考10A+而不能拿到,因为其他人也一样拿到10A+,你能这么说?你能好像现在这样,说 “我比他多哦”,当中华裔必须更警惕,因为这个等于变相让某些小拿破仑、种族主义的官员有更堂皇的凭借来把华裔优秀生踢出局!

恳请教育部从根本上解决问题,增加考试难度,提高水准!

强烈要求公共服务局透明化颁发奖学金!!!

5 comments:

Unknown said...

我也是要写,可是就是没有时间.....

Tze Howe, 9W2THO said...

now i holiday ma ..... hahahaha

QiYe said...

i agree with u, the education department should not limit the subjects taken. The important thing is to upgrade the standard.

sEnGz said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sEnGz said...

HaHaHa... I cannot read le, so ask pauloke read for me. He doing LI here too ma. I agree with wat you said. The standard has dropped compared to 10 years ago, its so rare to find a straight 9A1 student that time. Now, throw one stone in a school assembly also can easily fall on the head of a straight A student.

My opinion on this too is like yours, increase the standard and be stricter. Number of subjects should not be a limit, but the compulsory 10 subjects should be given emphasis first, the extra subjects as a tie-breaker while applying for scholarships.