Monday, May 25, 2009

愚蠢的民联绝食行动

民联在上诉庭宣布赞比里为合法大臣后,就宣布将进行绝食行动,并由民联阵营的火红人物 尼查和西华古马领衔打头炮。民联现在的战术目标只有一个,就是让霹雳州的课题继续燃烧三年,让国阵成为他们的提款机,不停的提取政治资本。绝食行动是司法对抗后的头炮,不过笔者本身对这个行动非常的有保留。首先这种做法属于非建设性的行动,其并不能提高民联的民望,政治上民联的确需要把人民对国阵的怒火燃烧下去,但是如果诉诸类似这种民粹的行动来争取人民支持,也未免太过一厢情愿了。

从行动上来看,绝食不失为一种非暴力抗争。国阵也摆明车马不会理睬类似的行动,民联行动成效的关键,就是在警方的反应。以过去警方有勇无谋,硬邦邦直挺挺的手段,肯定对类似的行动采取三个步骤  - 封锁、镇压、逮捕。这个才是民联要的状况。警察以暴力的手段对付非暴力的示威抗议,当然会丧失道德制高点。警察的笨蛋,加上民联的政治技巧,不失为延续民怨的方法。

只不过这种做法对国内的政治环境并没有一种正面的影响。民怨只会对社会的发展带来停滞。倒不如做一些比较有建设性的工作,比如整合民联控制的四个州属,推出一系列利民的政策,让人民看到民联是一个新兴、可靠的力量。绝食、示威,倒不如向民众呈现更民主、更具建设性的政权。

如果只是要夺回政权,那么越害怕失去,就越容易失去。

22 comments:

keykok said...

民联会说他们先宣传,后做事......

己为 said...

米已成粥,民联在霹雳已经确实失势了。好好做个称职的在野党,好好监督和制衡,下一届大选还是有机会的。政党做的一切,人民看在眼里,三四年后自然有判断。民联的议员还是好好收拾心情,继续为民服务,处理民生问题,制衡和监督政府,不要再搞多多pattern了!

Tze Howe, 9W2THO said...

在这个时代,包装和做事一样重要,奥巴马就是一个很好的例子。

不过马华几乎包装和做事都有待加强。

期待着翁诗杰落实直选的改革

Anonymous said...

先宣傳後做事...
好過馬華,宣傳後不做事...

哈哈哈... 老翁別告我哦...

正义之士 said...

相比之下,那些抓人的警察愚蠢。

能不能不要让他们那么蠢,看着难受。


马来西亚真是成了鸟国了。

georgefrlee said...

斗争是不可以结束的!虽说绝食行动可能是一些小插曲,也足以证明国阵以警察暴力来镇压一个和平的绝食运动。

3只青蛙议员的一跳就让我们人民的希望变成失望,值得吗?要做的事情,要让苏丹知道霹雳州人民的意愿,不是吗?

Anonymous said...

Before you label other people's action stupid, look into the mirror first. What you have said does not appear to be too smart anyway.

Anonymous said...

看来几位仁兄也是鸟人。是,我们是厌倦争夺。但是重点是你们要查看事件的源头根本。方案是必须还政于民,只需重选,就是解决当前发生执政问题。但是之后引发的警察故事,国会也必须探讨。他?算了吧,没用的家伙。

Fairnation said...

1。先要弄清绝食是非建设性的行动,还是非破坏性的行动?

2。是非法集会, 还是公民不合作运动?

3。被人当了政治提款机,是断臂止蚀比较聪明还是继续被人提款提到完全失血为止比较聪明?

4。警察是笨蛋,但警察是内政部管辖的。警察拥有有谁的祝福才会有行动呢?是谁祝福这些笨蛋?

5。你说只不过这种做法对国内的政治环境并没有一种正面的影响。
没有听过No Pain, No Gain吗?学习最快的方法就是经过痛苦。
有人会否认经过308种种事件后,人民的民主意识没有被大幅提高吗?

haha said...

fasting is used by many popular politician of all time...may be not popular in Malaysia...If it can change a country as huge as British empire...do you think it will change Malaysia?
By the way, there is no hope in our government! We don't care whether they will hear the people's voice or not. Cause I bet they won't, and they judge us through their perspective.
At least there is someone to stand up against these cowards (Police, Judge, Ministers, and most important the "U" club). You have to praise them for their courage to stand against all authorities...I bet if they loose the next election...They will unleash the ARMY again...like 513...
Brothers and Sisters, please remember what our own people had suffered in the darkness of 513.
The more the "U" club thinks we are stupid, we will continue to work on it. It's not only people who we elected, should serve us (the people). We (as a Malaysian) have to stand up together to open up a new page, like what Singapore had achieved since 1969. We (as one nation and one race [Malaysian], should believe that without the "U" club, we can bring peace and prosperity to us.

Tze Howe, 9W2THO said...

哈哈。以上说的都没错,

我只是认为,如果民联要取代国阵,那么一定在政策上取胜。。。。

那才是转型为执政党的关键!

难道要做万年反对党吗???

Anonymous said...

keykook so free talk nonsense here? no need help your boss prepare more CD give for free?

>>如果只是要夺回政权,那么越害怕失去,就越容易失去。
You talk about MCA??

Anonymous said...

Tze Howe, 9W2THO said...

期待着翁诗杰落实直选的改革

rupanya orang MCA same as keykok.

Tze Howe, 9W2THO said...

我可不是马华的!

是马华的也好,是巫统的也好,都可以自由表达意见。。。。

谢谢您的留言

Ooi said...

民主运动需要全民前扑后续的不间断斗争,你躲在那边享受成果就算了,还在那边冷言冷语,打击民主力量。
也许你应该进去里面关几天才能真正想通,我想你也没有这份勇气吧。

Anonymous said...

From this article, we can see how shallow abt Malaysian youth ...

Sad we need something better not showing their photo abt so and so present the pondan something ...

haha said...

i think dun need to be locked up.
pls join gov uni...u will understand..."M" race is always racist, becos of their press, their teacher since kindergarden...influence them...until Uni...since doesn't give up...those rich ppl...who study in private college will not understand...i study in UPM...grad in 2002...but after 2002..."U" is operating inside destroying UPM on the whole...any "others" race [is classified as bloody foreigners] sometimes foreigners is treated better than the "others" race...we said one word...you will have 50 audience surrounding you...asking you not to challenge the "U" club, or the gov...what the f**k! Gov & "U" club inside uni...this is stupid...and this is barbarian act. If you study in Local Gov Uni, you will understand! I studied there becos I m from poor family, my result are not good. I simply choose first language, BM [I treat it as Bahasa Malaysia becos I m Malaysian] and 2nd language "English"...and I m from science stream. If you are poor...think again...if you think gov forced anyone of you to join private college or private uni...think again. What I have been through...and believe me...in my course...you will be surprised to find that...30% Malay, 30% Chinese, and 40% other races. It is a muhibbah course, after all it's Bahasa Malaysia. If kerismudin called it "bahasa melayu"...he is betraying his own father...who try so hard to bring the people together after 513...If "M"_Dog_yidin said he is good in Malay...think again...I could be better than him in Bahasa Malaysia...we are equal in terms of language itself...moreover i m from chinese school...i still he is b*llsh*ting about helping the development of Mandarin...To protect our own language [mandarin], we have protect it with our own soul!

haha said...

no matter you are from BN or PR...please believe one thing...without the "U" party...we can be as strong as Singapore in less than 50 years!
I don't think we have any choice, get rid of "U" party. Our beloved nation will be saved!

Fairnation said...

I bet if they loose the next election...They will unleash the ARMY again...like 513...

除非他们不要了手上的股票,否则513这类惨剧是不大可能发生的。
要发生先要过得了庞大的巫裔中产阶级那关。

Fairnation said...

哈哈。以上说的都没错,

我只是认为,如果民联要取代国阵,那么一定在政策上取胜。。。。

那才是转型为执政党的关键!

难道要做万年反对党吗???
-------------

只是想问问感想,大部分民联执政州的政策会烂过国阵吗?如果有,请问那里烂?

Anonymous said...

you are a great pretender, just like keykok.

you two don't ever dare to see what actually these "U know who" people did to people!

In the end, no matter how you said that not a MCA, you did carry MCA thinking, sla...ness thinking.

BTW, are you the one said in the previous post about "Freedom Speech" by leader of AUTOBOT?

From this post, you are clearly show us that you DO NOT understand what is freedom.

We do not need uniform men go around catching everybody for any kind of nonsense reasons, hunger strike is personal choice, to show his unsatisfy of something. One way to show he is a FREEMAN.

Not like you and keykok, a sla...

Anonymous said...

i wonder if u understand the situation in perak thoroughly? this state no longer a democratic state n constitutionalism faded away...