Wednesday, September 2, 2009

这场马华党争隐蔽的历史,解读背后的故事

这场马华党争隐蔽的历史,解读背后的故事

http://www.kwongwah.com.my/news/2009/09/02/48.html

二零零九年九月二日 下午二时三十七分

马华党争几乎是一个恶性循环,三年一小闹、五年一大闹已经成为惯例。近二十年来分别有林良实Vs李金狮、林良实Vs林亚礼以及现在的翁蔡之争。纵观马华党争,除了林苍佑和陈祯禄之间的君子之战可以勉强称为政策之争,其他都是赤裸裸的争权夺利。

和巫统做个比较,马华组织的操作方式其实和巫统有很多相似的地方 一样是以党治国,党主席(当权派)拥有至高无上的权利。但纵观巫统创党至今,偶有党争但不曾像马华这样频密。关键就在于资源分配。巫统是真正的执政党,马华只是巫统的附庸,在资源分配上永远没有主动权,只能从巫统手中分配到一些杂质。无论是权力金字塔顶端的阁员分配,到基层的县市议员,甚至在铁幕背后的政府工程分配,马华只能跟从。

在资源极度短缺的情况下,那么全党由上至下将展开争夺战,以便可以分享到有限的蛋糕。林亚礼和林良实因为接班人问题开始闹僵,牵涉到的是部长职位之分。蔡细历和翁诗杰之间争的就多样化了。在部长职上两人的博弈,到纪律委员会和州联委会主席,以及柔佛州县市议员名单上交过手。蔡细历争纪委会是要自保免暂时搁置的案件将来遭到清算,部长是最大的资源来源,州主席则是资源分配的制定者,县市议员则是他们安插及培养基层的养分。这些才是他们党争的核心。其他理由只不过是掩饰的借口。

在这点上巫统的做法其实相当成功。它以大大小小官职捆绑党员,官职分配完了可以分配官联公司董事职衔,再不够可以分配政府工程、分配执照、F级承包商地位等,明目之多绝对可以让你眼花缭乱。当权者以资源分配的权利换取基层党员的效忠。基层基于不想影响到本身现有的利益,大多选择乖乖听话。以上情形已经成为马来西亚官场的潜规则。任何形式党争的开始,就是触犯以上潜规引爆的。

再说马华党争,要比算命老更准确预测谁人可以脱颖而出,看看国阵主席的脸色就可以得知一二了。要数这类戏剧化的演变就得看陈群川。当年梁维泮因触怒马哈迪而遭革除部长职,一夜之间众叛亲离,让陈群川水涨船高。可以说陈群川间接靠马哈迪上台。据闻陈群川入狱也因为他大搞民族经济事业而引起马哈迪的警惕不无关系。马华总会长成也巫统,败也巫统,不可谓不悲哀。

在这场翁蔡之争纳吉有没有表态呢?星期天首相署发表了一篇文告。当中指出星报专栏里所写的政府让翁诗杰单独面对巴生自贸区是没有根据的说法。“首相纳吉及政府支持翁诗杰和相关单位深入调查巴生自贸区有关事件”- 这是一个不寻常的讯息。纳吉的后盾让蔡细历不能以巴生自贸区课题攻击翁诗杰,同时也间接帮翁诗杰出去张庆信这个大敌,是力挺翁诗杰的具体表现,形成蔡细历的致命伤。

距离可能举行特大的日期还有大约一个月,政治上还有很多变数。且让我们看到时谁主王朝。

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

The Inconvenient Truth About Why Chua Soi Lek Was Sacked

http://mt.m2day.org/2008/content/view/26404/84/

读了就明白真向。

eddieliow said...

敬请留意,今晚 - 5-9-2009(星期六),傍晚6:30 - 7:00, 在ntv7 (Astro 107频道) 《追踪档案》播出武吉公满山埃采金事件。敬请收看!您用少少的时间和一点点的爱心将给于武吉公满居民无限的支持和关怀。

http://bancyanide.blogspot.com/
http://eddieliow.blogspot.com/

Kg Folk said...

You said that: ... 在这场翁蔡之争纳吉有没有表态呢?星期天首相署发表了一篇文告。当中指出星报专栏里所写的政府让翁诗杰单独面对巴生自贸区是没有根据的说法。“首相纳吉及政府支持翁诗杰和相关单位深入调查巴生自贸区有关事件”- 这是一个不寻常的讯息。纳吉的后盾让蔡细历不能以巴生自贸区课题攻击翁诗杰,同时也间接帮翁诗杰出去张庆信这个大敌,是力挺翁诗杰的具体表现,形成蔡细历的致命伤 ..."

You drew an inference by saying that our beloved PM is supporting OTK, thus making difficult for Dr. Chua SL. However, many people, MCA or non-MCA members have a varied thinking. All this while, OTK was saying he had been a lone in fighting cases against Tiong and his position as a minister is precarious and at stake. Earlier, Dr. Chua mentioned that cabinet and the PM had given him green light to investigate and asking him not to try to be hero and pretending to be threaten! So, do you think that this announcement is a help to OTK or it will bring some adverse effects to him by opening the eyes and ears of the MCA memebrs?

I refer you to read "Minister of Health, Follow PM’s KPI Requirements, Please … " and "WHO IS SPEAKING THE TRUTH?"

Mechanics of Solid said...

i am not so sure how much words we can trust from either ong or chua. i will only refer to the statement of pm as a reference. thats the 1st statement (if i am not mistaken) where PM release about PKFZ after Chua is sacked.

i feel that PM still support ong to be at the position and continue the investigation. to me it is jus simple logic.

might share your opinion ?

"asking him not to try to be hero and pretending to be threaten" do you mean this words is from Chua ? or PM? sorry to say i din really notice any statement from PM mentioning this. but from chua yes.